What Happens When a Trucking Company Violates FMCSA Rules?

Home » News » What Happens When a Trucking Company Violates FMCSA Rules?

What Happens When a Trucking Company Violates FMCSA Rules?

Truck accidents caused by trucking company violations of FMCSA rules can have devastating consequences. These regulations exist to ensure driver safety, prevent fatigue, and maintain vehicle reliability. When companies fail to comply—by pressuring drivers to exceed hours of service, neglecting maintenance, hiring underqualified drivers, or encouraging falsified logs—the risks of serious collisions increase significantly. Victims of these accidents often face severe injuries, long-term medical treatment, lost income, and emotional trauma.

The attorneys at Bentley & More LLP have extensive experience handling truck accident claims and lawsuits involving FMCSA violations. We thoroughly investigate each case, gathering driver records, maintenance logs, accident reports, and expert testimony to prove negligence. We also negotiate with insurance companies and, when necessary, take legal action to pursue maximum compensation. Our goal is to hold negligent trucking companies accountable while protecting your rights and helping you recover physically, emotionally, and financially.

For a free case evaluation and legal consultation with a skilled Anaheim truck crash lawyer, please contact us for more information.

Schedule a Free Consultation

Common FMCSA Rules that Trucking Companies Violate

When trucking companies violate one or more Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) violations, serious accidents and injuries can occur. Some of the most serious violations that lead to accidents include:

Hours of Service Violations

One of the most frequently violated FMCSA rules involves hours of service. Trucking companies sometimes pressure drivers to exceed maximum driving limits to meet tight delivery schedules. This rule is designed to prevent fatigue, but violations occur when companies prioritize efficiency and profits over safety. Drivers may feel compelled to ignore rest requirements – especially if performance metrics or bonuses depend on meeting strict deadlines.

Vehicle Maintenance Neglect

FMCSA regulations require regular inspections and maintenance to ensure vehicles are safe for the road. Some companies fail to comply fully, often due to cost-saving measures or a lack of proper oversight. Skipping maintenance or delaying repairs can lead to unsafe equipment. Trucks with worn brakes, tires, or other critical systems are more likely to experience mechanical issues that violate FMCSA standards.

Driver Qualification and Recordkeeping

Trucking companies must ensure that drivers meet the required qualifications and maintain accurate records, including medical certifications and driving history. Violations occur when companies hire underqualified drivers or fail to properly update their records. Pressure to fill positions quickly, combined with lax oversight, can lead to noncompliance with these rules, increasing the risk of unsafe operations.

Logbook and Electronic Logging Device (ELD) Misuse

Proper logging of driving hours through paper logs or ELDs is required by FMCSA. Some companies encourage falsifying records to appear compliant while allowing drivers to exceed limits. This practice is often driven by competitive pressures and a desire to maximize deliveries, ignoring the safety intentions of the rules.

Most Common Accidents Resulting from Trucking Company FMCSA Violations

Accidents Resulting from HOS Violations

Trucking accidents resulting from hours-of-service (HOS) violations are most often linked to driver fatigue. When drivers exceed the legal limits for driving hours, their reaction times slow, judgment becomes impaired, and overall alertness declines. This frequently leads to rear-end collisions – especially on highways where traffic can stop suddenly. Lane departure accidents and intersection crashes are also common, as fatigued truck drivers may drift out of lanes or fail to gauge traffic signals properly. Fatigue increases the risk of multi-vehicle accidents, particularly in heavy traffic or low-visibility conditions.

Crashes Stemming from Neglected Truck Maintenance

Neglecting proper truck maintenance is another major cause of accidents. Brake failures are one of the most dangerous outcomes, often causing rear-end collisions or jackknife accidents when a truck driver cannot stop in time. Tire blowouts are another frequent result, which can lead to rollovers or sudden loss-of-control accidents. Malfunctioning lights, mirrors, or safety devices increase the risk of side-swipe collisions and accidents during nighttime or adverse weather conditions, making proper maintenance essential for preventing serious crashes.

Collisions Resulting from Truck Driver Qualification Violations and Recordkeeping Violations

Accidents related to driver qualification or recordkeeping violations often occur when untrained or improperly authorized drivers operate large commercial vehicles. These drivers may mishandle turns, misjudge vehicle size, or fail to respond to road hazards, resulting in side-swipe collisions, jackknife accidents, and intersection crashes. Inadequate records prevent companies from identifying high-risk drivers, allowing unsafe practices to continue unchecked.

Crashes Due to Logbook or ELD Misuse

Misuse of logbooks or ELDs can mask violations of driving limits, effectively hiding fatigue or unsafe behaviors. Drivers who falsify logs may speed, make aggressive lane changes, or drive beyond safe hours. These behaviors commonly contribute to rear-end collisions, lane-departure accidents, and multi-vehicle crashes, particularly in congested highways or urban traffic.

Injuries that Truck Accident Victims Suffer

Whiplash and Neck Injuries

Truck accidents caused by FMCSA violations, such as fatigue or speeding, often result in severe whiplash or neck injuries. Sudden stops or high-impact collisions force the head and neck to move violently, straining muscles and ligaments. Victims may experience long-term pain, stiffness, and mobility issues, even after medical treatment.

Spinal Cord and Back Injuries

Collisions involving poorly maintained trucks or overloaded vehicles can lead to serious spinal cord and back injuries. Damage to vertebrae, discs, or nerves can cause chronic pain, reduced mobility, and, in severe cases, paralysis. These injuries often require extensive rehabilitation and may permanently affect a victim’s quality of life.

Head Trauma and Traumatic Brain Injuries (TBIs)

High-speed crashes or rollovers caused by driver fatigue or mechanical failures can result in head trauma. Victims may suffer concussions or more serious TBIs, which can lead to memory loss, cognitive difficulties, and emotional changes. Recovery can be lengthy and may not always be complete, leaving lasting effects.

Broken Bones and Fractures

Truck collisions often involve enough force to cause fractures in the arms, legs, ribs, or pelvis. FMCSA violations such as speeding, improper loading, or brake neglect increase the likelihood of high-impact crashes that lead to these injuries.

Internal Injuries

Victims may sustain internal bleeding or organ damage in crashes caused by truck company violations. These injuries are often life-threatening and require immediate medical attention, sometimes resulting in long-term health complications.

How to Prove a Trucking Company Violated FMCSA Rules and Caused a Crash

Collecting Accident Reports

The first step in proving a trucking company violated FMCSA rules is obtaining official documentation of the crash. Police reports, incident reports, and accident scene photographs provide critical information about the events leading up to the collision. These reports can show evidence of driver error, unsafe vehicle conditions, or other factors linked to FMCSA violations.

Examining Driver Records

Investigating the truck driver’s logs, including electronic logging device (ELD) records or paper logbooks, is essential. These records can reveal violations of hours-of-service rules, such as driving beyond legal limits without proper rest. Driver qualifications, training records, and employment history may also demonstrate that the company failed to meet FMCSA standards for hiring and supervising safe drivers.

Vehicle Inspection and Maintenance Evidence

Maintenance and inspection records can show whether the trucking company neglected FMCSA requirements. Evidence such as service logs, repair receipts, or recall notices can prove that the truck was unsafe due to worn brakes, tires, or other mechanical defects. Expert inspections can also identify mechanical failures that contributed to the crash.

Witness Testimony and Expert Analysis

Eyewitness accounts from other drivers, passengers, or bystanders can corroborate unsafe behavior or fatigue. Accident reconstruction experts can analyze skid marks, vehicle damage, and impact angles to determine whether FMCSA violations played a role. Experts may also testify about how specific company practices, such as speeding or inadequate maintenance, contributed to the collision.

Documenting Company Policies

Internal company communications, dispatch instructions, or safety manuals may reveal systemic practices that encourage rule violations. These documents can show that the collision was not an isolated incident, but the result of corporate negligence.

Recovering Compensation for Truck Accident Injuries

Medical Expenses

If a truck accident results from a trucking company violating FMCSA rules, victims can recover compensation for medical expenses. It includes hospital bills, doctor visits, surgeries, medications, and physical therapy. Any future medical treatment or ongoing care related to the accident may also be included, ensuring victims are not financially burdened by long-term health needs.

Lost Income and Loss of Earning Capacity

Victims who miss work due to injuries can recover lost income for the time they are unable to work. In more severe cases, where injuries affect a victim’s ability to return to their previous job or earn the same income, compensation can include loss of earning capacity. It ensures that long-term financial impacts are addressed.

Pain and Suffering

Truck accident victims may also receive compensation for physical pain and emotional distress caused by the collision. Pain and suffering covers ongoing discomfort, reduced quality of life, emotional trauma, and anxiety resulting from the accident. This type of compensation acknowledges that injuries affect more than just physical health.

Property Damage

Compensation can cover damage to personal property, such as a vehicle or other belongings, caused during the accident. It helps restore the victim’s property or provide the funds to replace it.

Punitive Damages

In cases where the trucking company’s actions were particularly malicious, courts may award punitive damages. These are intended to punish the company for egregious violations of FMCSA rules and to discourage similar conduct in the future.

FAQs: FMCSA Rule Violations that Cause Trucking Crashes

What causes trucking companies to violate FMCSA rules?

Trucking companies often violate FMCSA regulations due to pressure to meet tight delivery schedules or cut costs. Common violations include exceeding hours-of-service limits, neglecting vehicle maintenance, hiring underqualified drivers, and pressuring drivers to falsify logs.

What injuries can result from these accidents?

Victims may suffer whiplash, neck and back injuries, broken bones, internal injuries, or traumatic brain injuries. These injuries can be severe and long-lasting, often requiring extensive medical care and rehabilitation.

How do attorneys prove FMCSA violations?

Our attorneys gather accident reports, driver logs, maintenance records, witness statements, and expert analyses to show that a trucking company broke FMCSA rules. We also examine company policies and communications to demonstrate negligence.

What types of compensation can I recover for my injuries and other losses?

Victims may be entitled to medical expenses, lost income, loss of earning capacity, pain and suffering, property damage, and, in some cases, punitive damages if the company’s conduct was particularly malicious.

How can your attorneys help with my truck accident claim or lawsuit?

Our experienced truck accident attorneys handle every aspect of your claim or lawsuit. We collect evidence, work with experts, negotiate with insurance companies, and, if necessary, pursue litigation to maximize your recovery. We focus on holding negligent trucking companies accountable while protecting your legal rights.

Contact a Skilled Truck Accident Lawyer Today

At Bentley & More LLP, our attorneys are ready to fight for your legal rights and pursue the justice and financial recovery you need.

Reach out to us today to speak with an experienced Anaheim personal injury attorney and learn your next steps.

Schedule a Free Consultation